Why Roy Cooper's Senate Bid Isn't the Cakewalk It Appears to Be
As a North Carolinian who's watched our state's politics twist and turn like a mountain road, I've got to say: the conventional wisdom on Roy Cooper's 2026 Senate run is missing the mark. Sure, the former governor cruised through the Democratic primary with over 90% of the vote, and early polls show him leading
Republican Michael Whatley by anywhere from 5 to 10 points on average (RealClearPolitics average has him up +9.6, with recent surveys like Change Research at +10). He's got name recognition, a track record of winning statewide, and Whatley—former RNC chair and Trump ally—doesn't exactly light up the room. On paper, this looks like a comfortable pickup for Democrats in an open seat vacated by retiring Sen. Thom Tillis. But dig a little deeper, and you'll see why this race could tighten up fast. The MAGA crowd has a habit of under-polling, our recent gubernatorial history proves bad opponents can skew results, Trump still holds sway here, and let's not ignore the mess in the Mecklenburg Democratic Party or the growing frustration among Black voters. Buckle up—this isn't going to be as easy as it looks.
Polling and the MAGA Factor
North Carolina has long been a swing state where polls don't always capture the full picture, especially when it comes to Trump supporters. Remember 2020? Trump won here by 1.3 points, but many polls had it even closer or underestimated his rural turnout. Fast-forward to now, and Trump's approval rating in NC has declined, sitting around 41-44% approve with 48-52% disapproving in recent polls from High Point University, Catawba-YouGov, and others. That might sound middling overall, but among Republicans, it's still sky-high, over 80% approve of his job performance in primary-era surveys. And in a midterm year with Trump back in the White House, his base is energized despite some softening. MAGA voters often fly under the radar in surveys; they're less likely to respond to pollsters, but they show up on Election Day. Whatley's tied himself tightly to Trump, earning the president's endorsement and campaigning on "America First" policies. If Trump's hold in rural and suburban NC persists—especially among core Republicans—it could drag Whatley across the finish line. Cooper's leads look solid now, but we've seen these gaps evaporate before when the silent Trump contingent mobilizes.
The Ghost of Elections Past: Josh Stein's 2024 Win—and Cooper's Tight Trump-Year Victories
Democrats love to point to Josh Stein's 2024 gubernatorial blowout as proof NC is trending blue, but let's be real—it wasn't a referendum on policy; it was a demolition derby courtesy of Mark Robinson. The Republican nominee imploded with scandals, including those infamous posts on a porn site called Nude Africa, where he allegedly ranted about everything from slavery to calling himself a "black Nazi" and other disturbing comments. Stein won by double digits, but that was against a candidate who was toxic even to many Republicans. Without Robinson's baggage, that race would've been a nail-biter, much like Cooper's own tight reelections as governor. In 2016, with Trump on the ballot for president, Cooper eked out a win by just over 10,000 votes (0.2%) after a brutal recount against incumbent Pat McCrory, even as Trump carried the state by 3.6%. In 2020, another Trump year, Cooper won reelection against Dan Forest by a 4.51% margin (51.52% to 47.01%), the second-closest gubernatorial race of the 2020 cycle after Puerto Rico and the closest in any U.S. state. NC isn't suddenly a Democratic stronghold; Trump carried the state in 2024 (and previously in 2016 and 2020), proving there's still plenty of red in the Tar Heel mix. Whatley's no Robinson, he's a White party insider with fundraising chops and Trump's backing. If Republicans unite behind him, Cooper's "proven winner" status might not hold up as well as Dems hope, especially with Trump's influence looming in this midterm without a scandal-plagued opponent to drag down the GOP ticket.
Why We’re Targeting Whatley—and Why Your Support Matters Now
That’s exactly why we’re zeroing in on Michael Whatley in this cycle. As Trump’s hand-picked “recovery czar” for Western North Carolina after Hurricane Helene devastated the mountains, Whatley promised swift federal aid and rebuilding. Yet here we are, well over a year later, with communities still mired in red tape, facing evictions, incomplete infrastructure repairs, and families waiting on the help that was supposed to arrive. Whatley has dodged accountability for the slow recovery, preferring to pivot to Senate campaigning rather than own the failures on his watch.
This isn’t just a policy critique—it’s a glaring vulnerability we can and will expose. Just as North Carolina voters and activists helped dismantle the candidacies of Madison Cawthorn (whose scandals and extremism cost him his seat in 2022) and Mark Robinson (whose self-inflicted implosion handed Democrats the governorship in 2024), we have the blueprint to do the same to Whatley: relentless messaging, hard-hitting ads, grassroots mobilization, and voter turnout that turns his record into a liability. Your support—through donations, sharing the message, and getting involved—funds exactly that effort: the digital ads that reach rural voters, the door-knocking in hard-hit areas, and the voter registration drives that counter suppression tactics. This race isn’t won on paper; it’s won by showing up and fighting smart. If we want to protect this seat and deliver real accountability for Western NC, we need to act now.
Democratic Disarray in Mecklenburg County
Speaking of unity, the Democratic Party in Mecklenburg County—our state's biggest blue bastion—is in disarray, and that's a red flag for turnout. In the recent primaries, voters ousted two incumbent Democratic state reps, Carla Cunningham and Nasif Majeed, in landslides after they sided with Republicans on key veto overrides under Gov. Josh Stein. Cunningham faced heat for controversial remarks on immigrants ("all cultures are not equal") and voting to force local sheriffs to cooperate with ICE, while Majeed crossed the aisle on issues like gun rights and LGBTQ+ restrictions. The state Democratic Party even revoked their access to resources as punishment. This isn't just infighting; it's a sign of deeper fractures. Progressive challengers swept in, signaling that the base wants more ideological purity. But in a general election, that could alienate moderates or suppress enthusiasm if voters feel the party is too focused on internal purges. Mecklenburg drives Democratic votes statewide, Charlotte alone is a powerhouse, but if the local party stays messy, it could hurt Cooper's margins where he needs them most.
Frustration Among Black Voters
And we can't overlook Black voters, who make up about 20% of NC's electorate and are crucial to any Democratic victory. There's real discontent brewing here, and it's not hard to see why. Recent redistricting efforts diluted Black representation in congressional districts, such as dropping the Black voter share in CD1 from higher levels under the guise of "partisan fairness," sparking lawsuits (though some were later dropped). Add in ongoing concerns about voter registration challenges disproportionately affecting Black and brown communities, and you get a sense of systemic frustration. Black turnout was strong in the primaries, ousting incumbents who "voted against their interests," but that energy came from anger at Democrats who compromised on key issues like immigration and vetoes. If Black voters feel Democrats aren't fighting hard enough against Trump-era policies or delivering on economic promises, some might stay home or even peel off. Stein's win relied on massive Black mobilization; Cooper can't afford any slippage.
Look, Roy Cooper's a steady hand who's won tough races before, and he's got advantages and broad appeal. But North Carolina's politics are volatile, and midterms often favor the party out of power, right now, that's the GOP holding the Senate majority they're desperate to keep. With Trump looming large, MAGA undercurrents, and Democratic internal woes, this race could flip from "lean Dem" to "toss-up" overnight. We've got months of ads, debates, and surprises ahead, and in NC, nothing's ever as easy as it looks.
That’s why we’re going after Whatley now. Donate now to help us define Whatley before he tries to define himself.
DBW
David B. Wheeler is President and Co-Founder of American Muckrakers and lives in Western North Carolina. His views are his own, and written directly by David, with spell checking and minor edits with the the help of his AI buddy. An essay or story is never independently generated by AI and posted. That would be just stupid.
👉 Support this work
Disclaimer
This essay constitutes protected speech and commentary, opinion, and advocacy on matters of public concern under the First Amendment to the United States Constitution. It is not a legal pleading, sworn statement, affidavit, or admission of fact, and it does not purport to describe evidence, discovery, or litigation strategy. This commentary is not intended to influence any pending judicial proceeding. Nothing herein waives any rights, concedes any legal position, or limits the author’s ability to pursue or defend lawful claims in any forum.
Copyright © 2025. All rights reserved. American Muckrakers PAC, Inc. and David B. Wheeler. This work may be reproduced or republished for non-commercial or promotional purposes if you ask nicely. It may not be used for commercial purposes without the express written consent of American Muckrakers PAC, Inc. and David B. Wheeler, or else.
Paid for by American Muckrakers PAC II. Not authorized by any candidate or candidate committee. Donations to American Muckrakers are not deductible for state or federal tax purposes.